27 November 2020
The new federal law on improving the compatibility of work and care for relatives leads to numerous innovations, particularly in labour law: In future, employers will be obliged to continue to pay salary to employees who are absent for brief periods for the necessary care of relatives. In addition, parents of children with severe health problems will in future be entitled to paid care leave of up to 14 weeks. The new legal provisions will come into force in stages on 1 January 2021 and 1 July 2021.
Employees with care or custody obligations are already entitled, under certain conditions, to exemption from their obligation to perform work and possibly also to continued salary payments in order to fulfil their obligations towards their children, other relatives and close persons during working hours. The relevant legal provisions can be found in article 36 para. 3 Swiss Labour Act (LA; in German Arbeitsgesetz [ArG]), article 324a Swiss Code of Obligations (CO; in German Obligationenrecht [OR]) and Art. 329 para. 3 CO:
Pursuant to article 36 (3) LA, employees are entitled to exemption from the obligation to perform work for the time required to care for sick children for up to three days per event upon presentation of a medical certificate. The care of other relatives or close persons is not mentioned. Nor is continued salary payment regulated in the LA.
The right to continued salary payment and, under certain circumstances, to a longer leave of absence from work for the care and support of relatives is regulated in article 324a CO. An employee is deemed to be prevented from working (through no fault of his/her own) not only in the event of incapacity to work due to his/her own illness or accident. The employee may also be prevented from working by fulfilling his or her legal obligations, e.g. caring for his /her own children, spouse or registered partner. However, there is no statutory duty of care towards life partners or siblings. Whether the care and support of such persons, to whom the employee has "only" a moral obligation to provide care, also justifies a claim to time off work and continued salary payments in accordance with article 324a CO, has not been conclusively clarified legally.
The right to continued salary payments in accordance with article 324a CO exists in any case only as long as no alternative solution can be found for the care or, in the case of children, if the care provided by the parents is deemed necessary for medical reasons. The right to continued salary payments is also time-limited and depends on the years of service, whereby the employee's relevant absences, e.g. own illness, illness of a child, etc., are added together in the year of service in question.
For other cases, in particular for the care of sick family members for whom there is no statutory duty of care (e.g. siblings) or other close persons, e.g. life partners, the employer may grant employees extraordinary free time ("usual hours and days off") on the basis of article 329 para. 3 CO. However, this is only intended for cases of short-term leave of absence from work if it is not possible or reasonable for employees to use their normal time off work. Article. 329 para. 3 CO does not provide for an employer's obligation to continued salary payments. Such an obligation must either be contractually agreed or customary (article. 322 para. 2 CO). For employees on monthly wages, it is customary for salary to be paid for such absences.
In August 2018, the Federal Council noted the increasing importance of employed relatives caring for their sick family members. The reasons for this are a growing need for care and support that cannot be met by the health system alone, new forms of family cohabitation and the steadily rising employment rate among women. These reasons led to the presentation of the new federal law, the objectives of which are to improve the compatibility of employment and care for relatives and to create legal certainty.
Paid leave to care for relatives
According to the new legal provisions (in the CO and LA), employees are not only entitled to time off work and continued salary payments in the event of brief absences from work for the necessary care of children, but now also for the care of family members or their life partner.
What conditions must be met?
Family members are relatives in ascending and descending line, i.e. mainly parents and children, as well as siblings. In addition, spouses, parents-in-law and life partners who have been living in the same household as the employee for at least five years are covered.
Furthermore, the relative must have a health impairment. This term is broadly defined and does not only refer to an illness or an accident, but also, for example, to a disability.
The care provided by the employee must be necessary. The necessity depends, among other things, on the availability of other persons who could intervene in a reasonable way. The need for care is also a criterion. In the case of smaller children, for example, care is more likely to be necessary.
The new law does not explicitly mention the presentation of a medical certificate. Nevertheless, employees are still required to provide evidence of the facts justifying their claim, in particular the health impairment of their relatives. As a rule, this evidence should therefore continue to be provided by presenting a medical certificate.
What is the duration of the care leave?
Leave is limited to the required duration, but not exceeding three days per event. The leave entitlement therefore applies once per individual, specific impairment, even if it lasts longer or occurs repeatedly.
There is also an annual ceiling of a maximum of ten days per year of service. This means that an employee may take care of several dependents in one year of service as long as the conditions are met and the total absences does not exceed ten days.
It should be noted that the limit of ten days does not apply to the care of children with health problems.
Entry into force
The new rules on three-day care leave will enter into force on 1 January 2021.
Care leave and care allowance
Working parents find themselves in a very difficult situation when a child's health is severely or long-term impaired by illness or accident. The care leave and entitlement to a care allowance are intended to relieve the burden on these employees and provide them with better protection.
In future, working parents will be granted 14 weeks' leave to care for a child who is seriously impaired due to illness or accident. The loss of earnings will be compensated through the compensation scheme for loss of earnings (in German Erwerbsersatzordnung [EO]) (the "care allowance").
Who is entitled to care leave?
The entitlement to care leave according to the CO only exists if the employee is also entitled to care allowance according to the EO.
The care allowance is granted to parents of a minor child who has severely impaired health. This is linked to the child relationship in accordance with art. 252 of the Swiss Civil Code.
Serious health impairment is defined by law and occurs when (i) a significant change in the child's physical or psychological condition has occurred; (ii) the course or outcome of this change is difficult to predict or is likely to result in permanent or increasing impairment or death; and (iii) there is an increased need for parental care.
It is also a condition that at least one parent is employed or self-employed and must interrupt work. The need to accompany, care and support must be confirmed by a medical certificate.
This is to be distinguished from moderately severe health impairments that require hospitalisation or regular visits to the doctor and make everyday life more difficult, but for which a positive outcome can be expected or the health impairment can be controlled (e.g. bone fractures, diabetes, pneumonia).
In contrast to the allowance during maternity and paternity leave, no prior insurance and minimum period of employment is required for the care allowance.
Length of care leave and care allowance
The entitlement to care allowance and leave arises per occurrence of illness or accident. The maximum period of care leave is 14 weeks and can be taken within a framework period of 18 months. The framework period begins on the day on which the employee receives his first daily allowance. The care leave can be taken on a daily basis or in one block.
If both parents are working, each parent is entitled to a maximum of seven weeks' care leave. However, they can also agree on a different division of the leave. The employer does not have to approve the change in the division, but must be informed of the arrangements for taking the leave.
How much is the financial compensation?
The care allowance is paid in the form of daily allowances by the compensation scheme for loss of earnings. The 14-week care leave corresponds to 98 calendar days, which is why persons entitled to care allowance are entitled to receive a maximum of 98 daily allowances. The daily allowance corresponds to 80% of the average income earned before the start of the care leave and is limited to CHF 196 per day.
Temporary protection period against dismissal and holiday entitlement
After the end of the probationary period, temporary protection against dismissal applies during the childcare leave. The corresponding protection period lasts as long as the entitlement to care leave exists, but for a maximum of six months from the day for which the first daily allowance entitlement arises. A dismissal during the protection period is null and void.
In addition, the holiday entitlement of an employee may not be reduced by the use of care leave.
Entry into force
The new provisions on 14-week care leave for children with serious health impairment will not enter into force until 1 July 2021. This should give the compensation funds enough time to introduce the new benefit.
Author: Anela Lucic